You are the founder of the Canadia Bank,
the largest bank in Cambodia. Can you present
us your bank, its main developments since
its formation and tell us why you decided
to create it?
I left Cambodia in 1980 to go to Canada.
The situation in my country was quite unstable
and we wanted to go abroad to have a new
life. In 1988, I received a letter from
my uncle who had come back to Cambodia from
Paris. In that letter, he explained to me
that things had improved a lot in Cambodia
at the political and economical level and
that it was time for me to come back. So
in 1991, I came to Cambodia, met some businessmen
and government people and decided to establish
a business. While being in Canada, we had
a jewelry store and people were asking me
to send their money towards family members
in Cambodia. Although it began with small
amounts, in 1989 we were sending already
5 million USD, which is a huge amount. This
transfer of money concept gave the idea
to create a bank.
At that point, there was not much confidence
in the country and although the policy of
the Government was to attract foreign investment,
specially the one coming from Cambodians
living overseas, we decided to create a
trust company which was also able to provide
banking services. At that time there were
just 5 banks in Cambodia and my bank started
to flourish thanks to the UNTAC and its
soldiers that made a lot of deposits.
In 1993 the Governor of the Bank of Cambodia
approached me requesting me to formally
transform my trust company into a bank as
it was growing so fast. Although our initial
capital was not enough, the Governor told
me we could start already with 1.5 million
USD. As we had a lot of depositors and also
plenty of Cambodians from overseas trusting
in our bank, we managed to grow and currently
my bank's total assets amounting of 174
million USD. In deposits we have 150 million
and our reserves in 2002 totals 18 million
USD. Currently my deposits are about 26%
of the whole country's deposits and our
loans are about 32% of country's total.
Can you give us some other facts and
figures about your bank?
What concerns the customers, we do not
have the statistics on that, but mainly
we deal with local businessmen and other
foreign businessmen coming mainly form China,
Taiwan, Hong Kong, Singapore and Malaysia.
We have a hard time attracting Western businessmen
as they consider our country not to be reliable.
They prefer to deal with foreign banks,
as they do not have so much confidence in
local banks, my bank is local owned even
if the capital comes from foreigners, the
money is always in Cambodia.
We have a total of 12 offices throughout
the country one head office, one exchange
office and ten other branches. There are
290 employees from which around 100 are
security guards. This is needed to create
confidence with our customers. There are
no security companies to transport the money,
so I must provide the trucks to send the
money to our clients.
Since the application of the new banking
law, there are 17 banks left operating in
Cambodia, what would you consider are your
competitive advantages in respect to those
other 16 banks?
Before the application of the Banking Law,
there were a lot of speculators obtaining
a license for other purposes than just banking
in Cambodia. Others thought that with the
low capital requirements, just 5 million
USD, they could come to Cambodia to make
easy businesses, but in fact they were always
disappointed and their level of business
became so low that they had to shut down
or the Government revoked their licenses.
With the new requirements, there are just
17 banks left complying with the Banking
Law.
What concerns our competitive advantage,
we are creating the confidence in the people,
even during hard times, and we have stayed
while other banks, mainly foreign, ran away.
We even remained opened during the July
events in 1997. Everyone came to get their
money so we decided to limit the withdrawals
to a 1,000 USD per day and with the priority
to customers who had to deal with foreigners
in order to let them respect their payments
and keep on business. Luckily at that time
we had a lot of cash reserve, so we suffered
a lot for more than 20 days, but later when
everything cleared up, the depositors came
back. Since then we have an image of reliable
bank. Our money is here, not invested abroad.
We also have quite a high cash reserve,
between 52% and 48%, people is used to keep
a lot of cash for safety reasons. So Cambodia's
loan and deposit spread is very high because
a lot of bankers keep cash in hand. Another
thing is the solvency ratio of the Central
Bank, it is always higher than international
standards, so even when the normal ratio
is around 8%, in Cambodia is 20%, 2.5 times
the average, in Cambodia, every bank keeps
the cash.
Your bank is also known for its product
innovation, what are the main services and
products you are offering?
Our bank is the first commercial bank in
Cambodia to use the smart card system. We
integrated this system from a French company
called BULM. We were also the first banks
to introduce an ATM machine for my cardholders,
but it seems not to be so successful. This
is mainly due to the fact that Cambodians
are quite conservative and they always want
to have cash in hand. In 2001, we became
a principal member of MasterCard and a principal
member of VISA in 2003. This has helped
to increase the country's image.
|
Another of our advantages is our relatively
small size that helps us take decisions
quickly and easily on subjects like loan
requests. When it comes to loans, we know
the local people and business so we can
take decisions easily and efficiently. Also
my staff is part of my competitive advantage,
most of them are multi-lingual, making Chinese,
English and French investors feel comfortable.
We also have several facilities without
charge and we even offer some VIP services.
What other projects or services is Canadia
Bank developing?
In 2001 we have created our venture capital,
so when a client comes with a good project
and they have funding above 10% of it, we
take the project for study and if it qualifies
as a good project we finance the rest of
it. We have two conditions, the first one
is that we must manage the finances and
the second one is to obtain a good profit
share. It doesn't have to be seen as equity
participation, it is just a loan. So every
year the developer must pay interests, the
profit sharing and some small management
fee to the bank. With this way of working
we can help develop the country. There are
plenty of people with good ideas but no
money to implement them so our bank gets
involved and helps those entrepreneurs to
realize their projects. It is hard to find
businessmen willing to get involved in projects
above one million USD, but we already have
created an industrial park, a shopping mall,
a convention and multi purpose hall and
a cultural village with this formula.
You are mainly focused on the local
level but what are the plans of the bank
to internationalize its activities and get
involved in international projects?
International development projects are
not that easy to start. We started dealing
with IFC (International Finance Corporation)
and the World Bank, but with Cambodia's
image it is not so easy to get funding from
this kind of institutions. We presented
a project for renewable energy in 1999 with
feasibility studies included and after three
years we still have no answer. Some of my
clients ask if it is possible to obtain
from the IFC long-term low interest loans,
but in fact in Cambodia it is difficult
to find this kind of projects. Mainly also
because of the competition big projects
should have to face with our huge neighbors
Vietnam and Thailand.
In order to get into the international
scene, do you think you would need to create
a strategic alliance or a partnership with
a foreign institution?
We started up one project with a German
financial institution called KfW. They prepared
a 10 million EUR grant to Cambodia and asked
the Ministry of Finance to chose some banks
in Cambodia as their partner to run an SME
(Small and Medium Enterprise) project. Our
bank was chosen, as we are quite active
on the small business loan. So, they sent
a consultant to our bank and the project
was approved.
We are interested into obtaining long term
funding, I am talking of ten years with
three years grace period. The problem you
encounter in Cambodia is that if you deposit
1 million USD, 48% to 52% of it must remain
in the bank. So our target is to find foreign
financial institutions to have long-term
local funds for economic development. My
loan interest now is 12%, just the prime
rate. This is very hard for local businessmen,
we have to reduce the interest rate.
With all your experience in the Cambodian
banking system, what would you say are the
strengths and weaknesses of this system?
One of the points to improve is to be really
connected with foreign financial institutions.
Not only at the technical or the management
level, the most important is the funding.
We have had a good start but I think this
is a long process. The moment we start to
have a more attractive long term, low cost
funding, and industries will start to get
profitable. The factories can deal with
a 7% or 8%, but 12%, as it is currently
it makes its development quite hard.
On the positive side, the Cambodian banks
have little Government intervention and
although the start-up requirements are quite
high, the Governor of the Central Bank does
not ignore the banker's needs. The Government
has established a working group with the
banks and the Banker's Association to ask
their opinions about new issues. They see
the banker as a partner and they want to
know about their problems and their opinions.
Do you have any kind of training policy
for your own staff in order to develop their
skills?
When we started our bank, most of the management
team was former employees of the National
Bank or people we had brought over from
Canada or France. We required university
level and mastering several languages. Currently
we have training programs on Saturday for
languages and internal management. We also
encourage them to acquire computer skills
and to obtain new degrees by paying them
50% to 80% of their fees. We also send employees
to seminars abroad to improve our bank staff's
skills. So, as you can see our bank is indeed
committed to help our staff develop.
What would be your final message to
foreign investors willing to come to Cambodia?
My opinion as a bank manager is that when
a foreign investor decides to come to Cambodia,
the first thing he has to do, is to choose
a good partner. Second, there is a need
to maintain a good communication at the
right government level and also at a right
timing. The most important thing is you
need to do a good market research. Choose
a good project with a good partner and invest
the money in research.
|