Kyrgyzstan
Striving towards democracy and economic development


V.I.P. INTERVIEWS
H.E. Mr. Tanayev, Nikolai Interview with
H.E. Mr. Tanayev, Nikolai
Prime Minister of the Kyrgyz Republic
August 8th, 2002


Kyrgyzstan has gone through a number of changes in the last few years. Could you describe or brief us on the most relevant ones, how the economy of Kyrgyzstan has improved and the further improvements that you expect?

If you allow me I will explain what our actions are. In fact our country will be celebrating the 11th anniversary of its independence this year. And of course as all other CIS countries we were born in the socialist system, state type of property and the government property and socialist manufacturing relationships, and for the previous 10-11 years we have been completely converted into free market relationships. In 1992 we started to introduce our local national currency. In fact we mainly privatized the state sector. In fact I cannot remember now the exact percentage of companies with the state ownership, but I can assure you that there are only very few government enterprises with the government property. So we have some recreation, health resorts or sanatoria, if I may say so, which are located in a nice Issyk-Kul area, some of which are still in the government property, but we are planning to privatize all of them till 2004. We will completely privatize housing facilities. The land is already in the private property, private hands. As I know it has not yet been the case in many other former Soviet Union countries. We have completely and fully privatized all companies or collective farms belonging to the agricultural sector. We don't have any collective farms belonging to the government. The whole of the banking sector belongs to private people. So the only things that are still belonging to the government are the buildings of the governmental agencies, ministries, and agencies. The energy sector started to be capitalized partically. So, the economy of the Kyrgyz Republic, since it acquired its independence has changed from socialism to capitalisms. And I can also tell what kind of difficulties and challenges we have met. The first challenge was that during the initial stage of denationalization and privatization it was the lack of experience, the absence of human resources who would work in the market economy. Then it was also difficult to break the mentality of those people who have been living for the period of seventy years in the socialist economy, when the state was completely responsible for the decision-making process in the past, but when we were converted to the market economy, people had to think on their own.

This is a long lasting process. For the previous 11 years we have been completely transferred to the market economy relations and we are building our future on the basis of market reforms. So what I can say that some of the consequences of that lack of experience lack of skills have resulted in some challenges, shortcomings. Like, for instance, we borrowed foreign loans, international credits and loans and in some places they were probably badly targeted, as a result of which a huge economic debt burden was created. Right now we have to learn from our own mistakes. And our government is undertaking at the current moment some steps to be able to get rid of unnecessarily existing burden, to be able to match the revenues and expense of the country and to develop the economy at the same time.

One of the major challenges for developing the economy is diversifying it into different sectors. Currently the economy of Kyrgyzstan is very much dependent on the mining sector and agricultural sector, while the industrial sector has been lagging behind and has not been able to catch up.

I would not say so. All sectors of the economy are developing slowly, gradually and eventually some of them provide more results, some of them provide fewer results. And the gold mining sector to what you referred doesn't play a significant role in the economy yet and the budget of the country. The reason for that is because there are two gold mines operating in the Republic. One of them is named Makmal gold which was constructed by us during the Soviet power in 1995, the second mine is Kumtor was built up and we installed the gold mine facilities there using the credit proceeds jointly with the Canadian company CAMECO in 1996. And till the previous year we have mined gold, we have sold this gold and repaid the loans. Only starting from the previous year we began to receive royalties. Last year it accounted for 280 mln.som out of 11 billion som in the budget. This year this amount is going to increase a little bit. So the indicators of the gold mining industry they play, in my opinion, a very significant role in the gross output, but not in what you sell. So that's why at the moment we may not say that our economy depends very much on the gold mining, however we have a lot of hopes for the future. This year we are planning to start building from the next year a new gold mine Taldy-Bulak Levoberezhny. From the next year we plan to mine gold there. The difficulties I can show in the development of the industrial sector. We have lots of that because in the past our industries were completely orientated to the supply and demand of the former Soviet Union. And right now our objective is to make the industry work for the export, which is a very complicated process. It heavily depends on the replacement of the obsolete equipment in this companies and the availability of the working capital in these companies. But of course the industry is developing. The agricultural sector plays a very important role in our economy. It accounts for 37% of our economy, which is a huge percentage. All products which are grown locally they are mainly consumed domestically in the Republic, but the rest go for export. SMEs (Small and Medium Enterprises) account for a large niche as well.


In terms of attracting direct foreign investments, which sectors designate relatively the most, and what is the current Government doing to attract foreign investments, are you offering tax incentives, what other methods of attracting FDI will you be using?

If you allow me I wanted to be pretty precise and tell you everything in a sequential order. I will cover everything. We are doing the following things in terms of poverty reduction, gradual improvement of the economy and attraction of direct foreign investments. First of all we are in the process of competing the administrative reform. If I may say that in the past we used to have about 50 ministries. At the point we are reducing them abruptly and getting rid of unnecessary structures. Right now we have 13 ministries and 12 other structures in the country. We have reduced ministries and agencies by 30%. Inside the ministries and agencies we have reduced the quantity of the headquarters apparatus by 30%. This year we are planning to make further reductions. By now we have reduced them by 6.4%. We are in the process of elimination of those agencies, ministries that have some overlapping functions. We are reducing bureaucratic barriers on the way of development of entrepreneurship, business. We have conducted a complete revision, audit of the regulatory framework starting from 1925. We have revised mainly all decrees of the Government issued by the previous Governments of the Kyrgyz Republic. I am talking about documents the number of which exceeds 4000. We eliminated them. We revised and reformed the whole system of licenses, whenever agencies are supposed to receive licenses.

Even in the year 2000 we used to issue 470 licenses, at the moment we reduced the quantity of licenses to 30. In October, the current year we are planning to complete the reform of the fiscal system. We recently introduced the system of a one-stop shop; if an entity is being created, like an agency, organization, it can get registration, receive its licenses and permits in one place. And right now we are still going on with our administrative reform. We hope to complete it this year. In terms of the judicial reform being carried out in the country. For the previous one a half years, we have managed to bring 76 laws in compliance with our Constitution. We introduced amendments to over 220 laws, amendments we introduced for the purpose of eliminating duplication in between laws. And in the month of September we are introducing the package of laws and regulations, which prevent from development of favorable investments. We are also carrying out the court reform.

Recently the decree of the President was issued in terms of creation of the third party courts. In other words we are working in the direction of eliminating barriers for foreign investors. We are also implementing some reforms in the banking sector. Our objective in the banking sector is to bring back the lost credibility of the banking sector from the part of residents, this reform is ongoing and I can't deny that it is going with some problems and pain. The reason I am saying all this is because there was the crises of some commercial banks last year and during the previous years. We need to avoid and completely eliminate this situation. To be back to administrative reform I would like to add one thing that we have completely changed the relationship of the structure between the central government bodies and the local government bodies. We have transferred the major part of functions from the central level of the government to the local level of the government. At the end of last year we conducted the elections to the local government bodies and 467 heads of aiyl okmotus (local village councils), which has never been the case before. I was the Chairman of the working group which dealt with the development of Tax Policy in terms of the tax liberalization. What we did we make some reforms in this sphere. We left some taxes at the level of local governments, to authorize local governments to decide on their own what to do with those taxes collected locally. In terms of industrial enterprises and SMEs last year we introduced the amendments to the Tax Code to reduce the tax burden on entrepreneurs and agriculture. But of course, everything what is done is in the framework of what we can do. What was mostly important among the achievements made by us last year was the development of the country's development strategy, the Comprehensive Development Framework (CDF). That's a long-term program and within the framework of this long-term strategy we are completing the development of the mid-term strategy named National Strategy for Poverty Reduction (NSPR). So the reason why we proceeded with the development of NSPR was that over 50% (57% to be precise) of our population lives beyond the poverty line.

And naturally one of our most important objectives is to solve the problem of poverty in the country. When we developed this program at the beginning we attracted the whole of the population in the country to its development: all entities and persons who we could like public associations, the banking sector, NGOs and international financial institutions. As a result of all people's discussion this program was approved at the congress of all people of Kyrgyzstan. The Government received the program, which was approved by all people. During the period of the 9-11 October we are going to present the National Strategy for Poverty Reduction to our donors and we hope to receive their approval. In connection with a heavy burden of external debt of our country as I already mentioned, last year our representatives made a trip to the Paris Club discussions as a result of which we received the approval for the restructuring of the Kyrgyz Republic debt for three years. If we are in a full compliance with those obligations undertaken by the country during those discussions in three years we expect that 67% of our debt will be written off. The rest part of our external debt will be restructured.

And to continue to reply to your questions with regards to investments, we don´t have any possibility to borrow loans under the guarantee of the Government. That is why our major objective right now is to create favorable conditions for attraction of domestic and foreign investments. Last year the Coordination Council for Attraction of Foreign Investments under the leadership of the President was created. So members of that council are as follows: the President of the country, the Prime-minister, the US Ambassador, the Resident Representative of the World Bank and two leaders of the companies who have been working for some time in our country. The Secretariat of the special representative of the President on attraction of foreign investments was created.

The matrix with regards to alleviation or reduction of barriers to attraction of foreign investments was created in which all barriers, which impede from the attraction of foreign investments, were included. And right now we are finishing the work on this matrix.

Those things, which I enlisted before, like the development and improvement of the banking sector, judicial system, court system and other are gradually included in the matrix. And in June we conducted the investment summit in Issyk-Kul in which we made the results of our work. During the summit we also received some remarks and proposals, suggestions from the part of investors, donors and those representatives to be further included in this matrix, to refine it and then to provide the final version of this matrix in the end of the year with regards to elimination of all those barriers. So we can observe at the moment the first success of all those things like in tourism sector, housing construction sector, as well as the manufacturing sector results. What is mostly important for us is peace and quietness.

Do you think there's enough awareness about Kyrgyzstan as investment destination in terms of international investors? Do you think when an investor thinks of a place to inject his funds he considers Kyrgyzstan? Is there enough being done to promote the country and make investors are aware of possibilities in the country offers?

Unfortunately I don't think they are yet completely aware of this. To be very open and frank Its in our country have left much to be desired till a recent time. And only since a recent time we have started to place things like these on the Web site. Not the whole regulatory framework is placed on the Web in English. That's a great disadvantage and I hope we'll manage to overcome it till the end of the current year. The rest of the things, which I mentioned, are included in the portal of the Government, CDF and the Council for Attraction of Foreign Investments. The second point, which I would also call a shortcoming, is that geographically the Kyrgyz Republic is quite a small country and people have not known a lot about us. But in our opinion, of course it's a bad part for the US unfortunately, and fortunately for us is that after the events of the 11th of September, the acts of terrorism in the United States, people have become knowing us better cause those events were connected with the dislocation of the anti-terrorism of countries and due to this he geography of awareness of our country has been extended. As I already mentioned we hope a lot for the conduction of two very important events: the CG (donor's) meeting which will take place in October in our country, which usually have taken place either in Paris or Tokyo which was done on the initiative of the President of the World Bank Mr.Wolfenson who visited the Republic in April, the current year who was very much impressed by what has been done in terms of CDF and the National Poverty Reduction Strategy. And the second event, which will be very important for us, is the World Global Summit conducted in dedication to the international year of mountains. The year of mountains was declared to be the international year of mountains by the President of our country: UNESCO was very supportive of us, and then UN was supportive. On all five continents this year there were continental forums conducted. This will be the resulting summit, which will take place in November in our country. We expect that Kofee Anan and the General Secretary of UNESCO and the delegations- representatives of more than 130 countries will visit us. We hope those events will provide us with the better ground to not only policy-makers and decision-makers, but also businessmen and tourists to know more about our country.

Do you have any other comments you would like to add or maybe a very brief message to our readers and visitors to our web site?

The message is about our country. There's no country in the world, which is more beautiful than our country. I respect Switzerland, but Kyrgyzstan is nicer. We have everything available in the Kyrgyz Republic like mountains, fields, forests, clean rivers, nice people, hospitable people, we have quite an amount of natural reserves, we have the place for business development, we have the places to invest money. And recently our President proposed the idea to turn Kyrgyzstan into the country of human rights. We are implementing this idea now. I invite everybody to visit our country. We meet investors as kings, it's our task. And whish peace to all people of all countries. Unfortunately this is what is missing in many countries of the world. We also need peace.

  Read on